Gold is generally used in jewelry, but this metal is costly. Due to this, people tend to use stainless steel and sterling silver in jewelry. However, these two metals have many differences from each other. Due to these distinctions, a debate arises on stainless steel vs sterling silver.
Many people consider sterling silver as the best alternative to gold. However, opposite minds consider stainless steel to be a superior option. Such different thoughts make choosing these two materials tricky for a newbie. However, don’t worry! In this article, I will discuss everything about these two materials. So, let’s get started!
Gerelateerd: Geborsteld Nikkel versus Roestvrij Staal
Overview of Stainless Steel & Sterling Silver
Stainless steel and sterling silver are two popular alloy materials. Their look and overall feel make them suitable for making jewelry. Stainless steel consists of iron (70-81%), carbon (around 1%), chromium (10.5%), nickel (8%), and some traces of other elements. However, iron, carbon, and chromium are the three main elements that make stainless steel.
Due to 10.5% chromium, stainless steel material is rust-resistant. The carbon concentration makes it stronger. On the flip side, sterling silver is an alloy material. It comprises pure silver (92.5%) and copper (7.5%). Due to 92.5% of silver, sterling silver is also known as 925 silver.
In fact, many sterling silver products carry the 925 branding. Interestingly, some manufacturers add small amounts of zinc or germanium to reduce the copper content. These additions help increase the material’s resistance to tarnishing. Both of these materials have diverse applications.
Stainless steel makes sheets, pipes, and many other products. Similarly, sterling silver is also helpful in creating a variety of products. However, this material is very popular for its use in decorative production, especially jewelry. Stainless steel was first discovered in 1913.
Due to its favorable properties, manufacturers started using silver to make various products. On the flip side, silver is an ancient material. Its usage has always been extensive. However, sterling silver is made by humans by adding 92.5% of silver and 7.5% of copper. Both of these materials offer many advantages and unique value propositions.
Differences Between Stainless Steel and Sterling Silver
Sterling silver and stainless steel have many differences. Due to those distinctions, people have different opinions about them. In the section below, I will cover all of their fundamental differences. They will help you know if sterling silver or roestvrij staal suits your needs. So, let’s drill down!
1- Material Composition
Both of these materials differ from each other in terms of their composition. It won’t be wrong to say that differences in composition provide a path to other differences. Stainless steel consists of iron, carbon, chromium, and many other elements (traces). Here is a table showing the chemical composition of stainless steel material:
| Element | Percentage (%) |
| IJzer | 70–81% |
| Chroom | 10.5% |
| Nikkel | 8–10% |
| Mangaan | ≤ 2% |
| Silicium | ≤ 1% |
| Koolstof | ≤ 0,08% |
| Fosfor | ≤ 0,045% |
| Sulfur | ≤ 0.03% |
Remember, the proportion of each alloy element can vary in different stainless steel grades. Conversely, sterling silver doesn’t have many alloy elements in its composition. Instead, it is mainly made of silver and copper. Their proportion is as follows:
| Element | Percentage (%) |
| Zilver | 92.5% |
| Koper | 7.5% |
The composition of each alloy element induces specific properties in materials. For example, 92.5% of silver makes sterling silver very soft and prone to bending. Conversely, the 10.5% chromium in stainless steel makes it rust-resistant. Due to this property, stainless steel is very popular in manufacturing industries.
2- Appearance & Look
Both stainless steel and sterling silver look similar. However, they have some distinctions in their look and appearance. The stainless steel material is grayish-silver in color. Moreover, it is shiny and looks very attractive. Interestingly, the shine of stainless steel is long-lasting. It does not fade quickly. So, jewelry made with steel remains in good shape for a long time.
On the flipside, sterling silver is brighter and has a silvery tone. Due to its silvery tone, it generally looks more similar to stainless steel. However, it gives off a warmer feel, differentiating it from its counterpart. It is shiny, but this shine fades away quickly. This material is more prone to tarnish, which affects its visual appeal.
3- Kracht en duurzaamheid
Stainless steel is stronger and more durable because it contains some carbon. The presence of carbon makes it hard and scratch-resistant. Moreover, its chromium content makes it rust-resistant. Even in harsh conditions, this material does not deteriorate at all.
Conversely, the sterling silver is less durable than the stainless steel. The reason is that it has 92.5% of pure silver. Remember, the silver is generally soft. So, it induces softness into the sterling silver as well. Due to softness, this material is more prone to bending and scratching.
Moreover, sterling silver is prone to tarnishing. This means it gets dirty and develops a yellowish coat on its surface, making it look ugly and weaker. Therefore, this material is suitable only for jewelry. I don’t consider it ideal for making any heavy-duty product. On the flip side, stainless steel is robust, helping us make reliable parts and products.
4- Cleanliness & Maintenance
Stainless steel is straightforward to clean and maintain in the long run. The reason is that this material is rust and tarnish-resistant. Even using them in moist conditions won’t make it rusty. This material also resists smudges and other unwanted fingerprints. So, this material does not need regular cleaning.
Moreover, you can clean it with a cloth if it gets dirty. On the other hand, sterling silver is very challenging to maintain. Why? Because it is not rust-resistant. Moreover, when exposed to air and moisture, this material undergoes tarnishing. This means that it makes unwanted dark or dull colors on the surface.
You’ll have to use special silver polishing to remove these darker colors caused by tarnishing. Not to forget, rusting is a serious issue in sterling silver. If jewelry made of this material is exposed to moisture, it can get rusty. Removing the rust requires additional effort. Therefore, I consider stainless steel a superior option for maintenance and ease of cleaning.
5- Rust Resistance & Tarnishing
Stainless steel has chromium (10.5%) in its composition. When this chromium comes in contact with air, it makes chromium oxide. This oxide layer protects stainless steel from rusting. Therefore, stainless steel parts don’t get rusty even in marine conditions. Moreover, this material does not tarnish over time.
On the contrary, sterling silver doesn’t have chromium. Instead, it has copper material. However, copper does not help show resistance against rust. Moreover, this material tarnishes over time. Tarnishing is a process in which material reacts with air and develops a yellowish-dark layer. This reduces the look and charm of the material.
Snel hoogtepunt: When not used, you should always keep sterling silver jewelry in airtight bags. This will protect it from tarnishing (getting darker layers on the surface). However, if your jewelry is already tarnished, worry not. The darker layer produced by tarnishing can be cleaned. Stainless steel jewelry doesn’t face such issues.
6- Hypoallergenic & Safety
Stainless steel is a very safe material. It does not cause any allergy, even if your skin is sensitive. So you’ll be able to wear stainless steel jewelry the whole day and be fine. Many medical instruments are made with stainless steel, indicating its safety. On the flip side, some people may be allergic to sterling silver.
It contains 7.5% copper, which is not safe for some people. This concentration can cause redness or other allergic signs. However, this happens only to those whose skin is sensitive. I recommend asking your doctor about whether you can wear sterling silver jewelry. If you don’t have sensitive skin, this material is not harmful to you at all.
7- Cost & Applications
Stainless steel is readily available everywhere. Moreover, the cost of this material is also very low, which is a significant advantage. However, stainless steel comes in different grades, and the price of those grades can vary from one grade to another.
On the other hand, sterling silver is a costly and premium material. Its high price is because it consists of 92.5% pure silver. Processing and using such a high content of pure silver is expensive. However, this pure silver increases its softness, making it best suited for luxury jewelry.
When it comes to applications, both of these can be used to make decorative jewelry. However, stainless steel is also suitable for heavy-duty applications. For example, it is used for watches, kitchen utensils, and other everyday devices. On the flip side, sterling silver is mainly used in jewelry. Its softness makes it unfit for any other use.
Voordelen van roestvrij staal
As I said earlier, stainless steel has been used for decades because of its endless features. All these features contribute to its use in various applications. Let’s discuss the key advantages of stainless steel material.
1- Highly Durable
Don’t underestimate the power of stainless steel. It is famous for its high durability and better strength. Therefore, it makes it challenging to get deformed and work for extended periods in various applications. Plus, the corrosion and moisture resistance allows a better life on your end.
2- Less maintenance required
Heb je genoeg van onderhoud? Vergeet al je gedoe met roestvrij staal, omdat je er na weken of maanden naar moet kijken. Bovendien heb je geen last van roest. Minder of geen onderhoud zorgt ervoor dat je in je comfortzone blijft en laat het je partner zijn voor langere periodes.
3- Various applications
Every single material in the home is made up of steel. It is the magic of steel and compatibility with various industries. Trunks to random boxes are made of stainless steel. The best part? Now, stainless steel is part of jewelry. You can reduce the overall expenses and get a long-term deal.
4- Lower cost
No need to invest in a box full of money! Stainless steel is a cheaper metal compared to gold, silver, or platinum. It is possible due to the low costs of raw materials and an easy manufacturing process. Plus, stainless steel saves you some bucks from the maintenance and durability. With steel, you are in profit.
Advantages of Sterling Silver
Sterling silver is not a 100% pure silver metal. Instead, it comprises 92.5% silver metal. 7.5% are many other metals that add to its strength and make it concrete. Sterling silver is more of an ornament piece being sold by the jewelers. Sterling silver rings, earrings, and necklaces are commonly found. Let’s discuss some key benefits that you get with this material.
Lees ook: Beste Indiase fabrikanten van roestvrij staal
1- Lichtgewicht
Whatever other metal, whether steel or iron, they all are heavyweight. But 925 sterling silver is a clear victor here! It has a compact design and lightweight metal. It saves you bucks because of less money and helps develop the rings that do not pressure your muscles when wearing.
2- Great Looks
In terms of looks, sterling silver is matchless. No one comes near to its glamorous look. That is the reason behind its use in jewelry sets. If you plan to buy a necklace and manufacture something stunning, don’t overlook the silver. Use it in your products and make them look excellent and efficient.
3- Easy to Shape
Thinking about the low strength of the silver, it looks like a disadvantage, right? That is true, but it will not be when you will know about the malleable features of silver. You can easily convert it into any structure and input creative designs. It saves time and gives a better appearance to the overall material. Moreover, sterling silver becomes unified with various styles of rings and necklaces.
4- Valuable
Silver has a history of centuries. Don’t think it is a new player that will get eliminated by gold or diamond. Even the silver coins have been traded. Such a value makes it an all-time favorite for antique collectors. Sterling silver does not lose much worth after use. Unlike steel, it is challenging to create such an impression. With this metal, you feel safer and more accessible to sell.
Veelgestelde vragen
Is stainless steel better than sterling silver?
It depends on the perspective from which you compare both materials. Generally, I consider stainless steel a superior option over sterling silver. This is due to better rust resistance, no tarnishing, strength, and durability of stainless material.
Is stainless steel jewelry good quality?
Yes, stainless steel is an excellent material for making jewelry. It does not rust and keeps its shine for a long duration. Moreover, it does not bend or get scratched quickly. These advantages indicate the quality of this material, mainly when used in jewelry.
Is stainless steel or sterling silver better for sensitive ears?
I consider stainless steel the best option for sensitive ears. However, you can also use sterling silver with mild to moderate sensitive ears. I only suggest avoiding silver if you have extremely sensitive skin.
What lasts longer, sterling silver or stainless steel?
Generally, their lasting effects depend on the care you take. Stainless steel, being rust-resistant, offers a better lifespan. It can last many years without showing any sign of rust or deterioration. Moreover, its carbon content makes it less prone to bending and breaking.
Conclusie
Let’s conclude—which material should you choose? There is no one-size-fits-all! Both of these materials (stainless steel and sterling silver) offer excellent advantages. I recommend choosing stainless steel if you want durability. It is an affordable option that provides an optimal lifespan with a nice visual appeal.
However, its jewelry looks a bit bulky, which is a drawback. Sterling silver is expensive but an ideal option for jewelry. It is lightweight, soft, and charming. However, I genuinely believe stainless steel is a superior option for making products other than jewelry. Its rust resistance and overall modern look make it stand out.
Heb je een topleverancier van roestvrij staal nodig?
Maak je geen zorgen; we hebben HXSCO met meer dan 20 jaar ervaring. Wij zijn een Chinese fabrikant van roestvrij staal met kwaliteitsproductie en betaalbare tarieven. Onze certificeringen garanderen de veiligheid van metaalproducten. Kijk niet verder dan HXSCO, een vertrouwde metaalleverancier.